Blog

Women’s March on Washington in Phnom Penh

On 21 January 2017, my friend Jo Snapp organized the Phnom Penh March of women on Washington in support of our sisters in the US. I made a short video tribute to the ladies, and gents, who showed up on the day, using the music of my all time favourite band Salt n Peppa.

 

logo1

Phnom Penh: One family’s personal tragedy highlights devastating impacts of forced evictions on women

It was an economic survival decision. After losing her home in 2012, Neang Vanne, from Phnom Penh’s Borei Keila community, left Cambodia in search of a more dignified life for her family. Unfortunately, she never managed to send any money back – the 23-year old woman died this month in a traffic accident while working illegaly in Thailand. She left behind a 2-year old daughter, a 6-year old brother, and two grieving parents.

Borei Keila residents made the headlines in January of last year, when some 300 families were rendered homeless during a violent eviction by land developer Phan Imex, backed by the municipal authorities. Before the incident, the community signed a contract with Phan Imex, agreeing to vacate the land in exchange for apartments for 1,776 families in 10 blocks of flats that the company was to build nearby. Suy Saphan, the owner of the company, backtracked on the deal in 2010 when she said Phan Imex would only be able to finish 8 out of the 10 promised buildings due to bankruptcy.

 

August 08, 2010 - Phnom Penh. People walk between the old and the new buildings in Borei Keila © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

March 30, 2010 - Phnom Penh. People relax in front of their homes in the old buildings of Borei Keila. © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

September 04, 2010 - Phnom Penh. Women who previously lived in another area of Borei Keila, were evicted from their homes to make way for the construction of the Ministry of Tourism building. They found refuge in the open area under the old Borei Keila buildings, while they wait to receive the apartments they were promised in the new buildings. Only 6 of the 40 families that were evicted from the Ministry of Tourism area received new apartments. © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

October 09 2013 - Phnom Penh. The market that used to be in the open area near the old buildings was forced to move. With the rent being too expensive for most shop owners to have a space in the new market, vendors set up stalls on the street and back alley behind the new buildings. © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

September 04, 2010 - Phnom Penh. A view of Borei Keila from the new apartments. To the left the construction site of the Ministry of Tourism building and to the right PPIU University.  © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

September 04, 2010 - Phnom Penh. The families that had been evicted from the Ministry of Tourism area receive the keys to their new apartments. A boy who helped with the move looks out from a top floor balcony in one of the new apartments. © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

July 07, 2012 - Phnom Penh. A family in the alleyway of the new apartments. © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

September 04, 2010 - Phnom Penh. The families that had been evicted from the Ministry of Tourism area receive the keys to their new apartments. The families clean the single room apartments before they move in. © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

February 27, 2012 - Phnom Penh. One of the old Borei Keila buildings is destroyed. Borei Keila used to be a housing complex for athletes in the 60s but became army barracks after the war. In the late 80s early 90s people moved in, buying apartments and buying or claiming the land between them. © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

April 21, 2012 - Phnom Penh. The new buildings seen from the area left vacant after the eviction. © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

 

Refusing to live at distant relocation sites, Vanne’s family stayed on with 117 others and moved into a self-made rickety plywood shelter in the area. Since then, her mother Phan Sopha has regularly participated in peaceful anti-land grabbing protests, mainly led by Borei Keila women who are calling on the authorities and the company to deliver the promised housing. Despite pledges from Phnom Penh’s governor Pa Socheatevong to solve the land dispute, city hall has so far been slow to act.

Before signing a deal with Phan Imex, 44-year old Sopha had her own business at the capital’s Orussey Market, where she sold cakes and earned up to 40,000 riel ($10 US dollars) per day. With her daughter selling coffee, her husband working as a daily labourer, and her son-in-law as a driver, they led a modest but happy life. “We had a small house and we were happy. We had electricity, running water and a bathroom,” Sopha said.

But the loss of the family home soon led to the breakdown of the family unit. Unable to cope with the financial burdens, Neang Vanne’s husband divorced her shortly after the evictions. At the same time Sopha’s husband was diagnosed with cancer, and due to deteriorating health could no longer perform strenuous physical activity.

And so Vanne had to assume the role of primary breadwinner. Like many of her peers, left with very few employment opportunities, she chose to emigrate to Thailand. Once abroad, she joined the swell of undocumented migrants and was quickly locked into unreliable and exploitative employment. “In the beginning, when she called me, she wanted to come back home but didn’t have enough money to do so. She worked at a construction site and was very weak,” Phran Sopha recalled.

Chan Soveth, Deputy Head of Land Rights Unit at local rights group Adhoc, believes Sopha’s tragedy, and the break up of many other Borei Keila families due to economic migration, was brought about by the land grab: “Since the evictions, many of the kids work in factories in or near Phnom Penh; others go to work abroad illegally to help support their parents. What happened to Sopha’s daughter is tragic, but who can be held accountable for that?”

 

October 12, 2013 - Phnom Penh. A woman with her new born child walks through the area behind the new buildings. Some of the families who were evicted in Jan. 2012, built shacks behind the new apartments. © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

October 12, 2013 - Phnom Penh. Sopha, Neang Vanne's mother, with her grand-daughter in their home. © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

October 09, 2013 - Phnom Penh. Monks pray in Borei Keila during the funeral ceremony of Neang Vanne (23) who passed away in a road accident in Thailand early in the month. © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

October 09, 2013 - Phnom Penh. Neang Vanne's little brother gets dressed for the funeral ceremony. While Vanne's daughter looks out the front door of their home. © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

October 09, 2013 - Phnom Penh. Guests sit down for a meal after the funeral prayer. Neang Vanne (23) was cremated in Thailand, and her mother held the ceremony as per tradition 7 days later near her home in Borei Keila. © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

 

Today Sopha barely manages to make ends meet. She sustains her household with the help of a non-governmental organization and the little income she generates from selling scrap. “I support my community and go to protests all the time. When I don’t protest, I have to look after my sick husband. Because of all that, I lost my spot at the market and now I don’t have enough money to start my business again,” she said.

Cambodian women usually bear the primary responsibility for caring for their loved ones. Therefore, according to a 2010 briefing paper by the human rights watchdog Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, the loss of material resources and livelihood opportunities that accompanies forced evictions increases demands on their time – and consequently also limits their future options. With a long list of chores, and a lack of access to meaningful employment, Sopha is falling further into poverty with every passing day.

Her story is a painful reminder of the complex myriad of impacts forced evictions have on the most vulnerable Cambodians – especially women. Losing their home is usually only the first in a string of many human rights abuses that families suffer. Miloon Kothari, former UN Special Rapporteur on the right to adequate housing, asserts women not only lose their homes but also tend to experience “the loss of livelihoods, relationships and support systems, breakdown of kinship ties, physical and psychological trauma and even increased morbidity and mortality.”

Suy Saphan, governor Pa Socheatevong and Long Dimanche, spokesman for Phnom Penh City Hall, could not be reached for comment.

  • Text:
    Marta Kasztelan
  • Photos:
    Nicolas Axelrod
  • Country: Cambodia
  • Year: 2013

October 12, 2013 - Phnom Penh. Neang Vanne's daughter plays with a friend at home. © Nicolas Axelrod / Ruom

– See more at: http://www.ruom.net/portfolio-item/mothers-struggle/#sthash.wArpH5ei.dpuf

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s